
Count the coils. Measure their diameter. And, if you have the equipment, measure their weight. Otherwise we can't say for sure -- your springs may be different from ours.
I've used the 60g variant in the brown Alps of my IBM 5140 keyboard here: post357579.html#p357579sneaux wrote: Has anyone tried these?
https://mekanisk.co/collections/keyboar ... -keyboards
I'm really enjoying the quiet click life right now, but am thinking about trying some heavier springs in hopes of a snappier upstroke. Sharper MX Clears without that obnoxious ping is what I'm aiming forI haven't heard anything about these though
They are cheaper on eBay:sneaux wrote: Has anyone tried these?
https://mekanisk.co/collections/keyboar ... -keyboards
I'm really enjoying the quiet click life right now, but am thinking about trying some heavier springs in hopes of a snappier upstroke. Sharper MX Clears without that obnoxious ping is what I'm aiming forI haven't heard anything about these though
FWIW, the quality of items in the trash was a factor in my university choice many years ago. I did manage to find an Itanium and an UltraSparc and many printers in the trash, but no super interesting keyboards, alas. Toward the end everyone started having mobile devices with e-mail (no iPhone, yet) and things got way more competitive.
Isn't the stock spring much lighter?Nuum wrote: I've used the 60g variant in the brown Alps of my IBM 5140 keyboard here: post357579.html#p357579
So far they feel fine!
I have the 65 cN's in my MatiasClick V80. Slightly heavier than stock, and feels a little more solid and stable. I feel like the heavier weight is a better match for the strong tactility in these switches. It's definitely an improvement but doesn't do anything about that "hollow" feeling Matias switches seem to have.sneaux wrote: Has anyone tried these?
https://mekanisk.co/collections/keyboar ... -keyboards
I'm really enjoying the quiet click life right now, but am thinking about trying some heavier springs in hopes of a snappier upstroke. Sharper MX Clears without that obnoxious ping is what I'm aiming forI haven't heard anything about these though
Yes, I think the stock spring in SKCM brown Alps switches is quite light, but I don't have any measurements on the spring itself. As you probably know, most of the resistance in the brown Alps switch is due to the tactile plate assembly.alh84001 wrote:Isn't the stock spring much lighter?Nuum wrote: I've used the 60g variant in the brown Alps of my IBM 5140 keyboard here: post357579.html#p357579
So far they feel fine!
I think it is relatively convenient to PM Hasu (at GH, or here?) for Alps64 PCB and then order a steel plate from Lasergist when you are in Europe.
Thanks for the ebay seller link btw. I didn't know the leaf added to the weight. That's kind of cool. But I guess with that information, I want to know mostly the same things that have been mentioned. What are the standard spring weights for typical ALPS switches (just the spring), so we could have a point of reference? And how does spring weight combine with weight from the leaf at different positions of the force curve?Hypersphere wrote: QUESTION about Alps replacement springs: How to determine which weight to get? What is the correspondence between the weight rating of the spring and the actuation or bottom-out force of Alps switches?
(Please forgive my cross-posting. I also posted this info and inquiry in a necropost on Alps springs; I was not sure anyone would read it, so I am also posting here).
"Spirit" is selling replacement Alps springs through at least two outlets:
1. eBay:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/222396774240?ul_noapp=true
(Scroll down to find the listings for Alps springs).
2. Mekanisk:
https://mekanisk.co/collections/keyboar ... -keyboards
I'd like to order some, but I don't know how to determine which weight I would need. What about doing the "nickel test" by using linear Alps switches as a spring tester to avoid the contribution of the tactile/click leaf to the switch weight?
I asked Sprit. Told him I wanted slightly heavier springs for Matias Click. He suggested the 65 or 70 cN. Seems like he knows what he's talking about.Hypersphere wrote: QUESTION about Alps replacement springs: How to determine which weight to get? What is the correspondence between the weight rating of the spring and the actuation or bottom-out force of Alps switches?
(Please forgive my cross-posting. I also posted this info and inquiry in a necropost on Alps springs; I was not sure anyone would read it, so I am also posting here).
"Spirit" is selling replacement Alps springs through at least two outlets:
1. eBay:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/222396774240?ul_noapp=true
(Scroll down to find the listings for Alps springs).
2. Mekanisk:
https://mekanisk.co/collections/keyboar ... -keyboards
I'd like to order some, but I don't know how to determine which weight I would need. What about doing the "nickel test" by using linear Alps switches as a spring tester to avoid the contribution of the tactile/click leaf to the switch weight?
Sounds like it might be binding.