chzel wrote: What would you suggest photekq?
They are coming to Europe. There is no stopping that, unless we start sinking boats. Greece (and Italy) have vast sea borders and Turkey doesn't seem willing/able to stop the refugees from getting on a boat.
Should we let them on the boats until they starve or sink? Do we rescue them? And after we rescue them what? Put them in camps until somehow we manage to send them back? Or act like actual empathetic human beings and try to help them live a modest life?
Apparently you believe immigration is an issue. What makes certain immigrants unwanted? Who is to decide?
Should the United States have refused German and Irish immigrants?
If I get a job and come to the UK for a year or 10, am I not an immigrant? Should I be denied access?
Also don't forget that most of these people are not just economic migrants. They are refugees, they are fleeing war.
Yes, there will be some that will try to take advantage of the situation, but that has to be sorted after they arrive.
EU can't just look the other side and impose border controls when Greece in January was getting on average 3500 arrivals EACH DAY. (
http://reliefweb.int/report/greece/gree ... 1-feb-2016).
Sorry, I did write a response to this a few days ago but my browser crashed. I couldn't be bothered rewriting it until now..
This is a bit of a wall of text, so I wouldn't blame you if you choose not to read it, but I would be very happy if you do.
I will reply in sections. Before starting, I will mention a few relevant things which may aid in understanding my point of view:
I have no hatred in my heart; not towards any peoples or any culture.
I'm a nationalist. Not just towards my own country and my own culture, but towards every country and every culture. I strongly believe that every country should be left to its own people, so that they may form their own path. Now, you ask "What if a country and its native population chooses to move towards multiculturalism?". If a country chooses that as their path then so be it. If it is the will of the people, then it is the path the country must take. However, I believe multiculturalism cannot work once the population of non-natives reaches a certain point - anything over 10% and you will see problems spring up more and more frequently. An exception to this would be migration of Europeans within Europe, as our countries have such similar values. I imagine that if there were a country comprised of an equal mix of British, Italian, German and French people everyone would get on reasonably well. That said, I would still not encourage such migration. I do not see any advantage to multiculturalism, and I will fight against it until I pass. It pains me deeply to see the unique, beautiful cultures of the world become more dissolute.
I do not pay attention to the popular media, and I'm not easily scared by fearmongers. I try my very best to only pay attention to the facts, although that can be very difficult in this world of lies.
What would you suggest photekq?
They are coming to Europe. There is no stopping that, unless we start sinking boats. Greece (and Italy) have vast sea borders and Turkey doesn't seem willing/able to stop the refugees from getting on a boat.
Should we let them on the boats until they starve or sink? Do we rescue them? And after we rescue them what? Put them in camps until somehow we manage to send them back? Or act like actual empathetic human beings and try to help them live a modest life?
Ok. You would like to hear my ideal solution? I say that it should be made clear to all attempting to reach European shores/borders that they will be turned back if they manage to do so, that they should halt any attempt to get here. The EU and its constituent countries should offer Greece and other countries aid in protecting their borders. (Of course, this won't ever happen.) This should be done until a method of differentiating true refugees from economic migrants has been established. || I should mention here that I do not know where you found evidence that supports your statement "most of these people are not just economic migrants. They are refugees, they are fleeing war.". Even Eurostat, the official EU statistics agency, claims that only 1 in 5 migrants are refugees from Syria. The majority of these people are not refugees, they are economic migrants. Also, the vast majority of those coming in are lone men, not women and children. You realise that most of these men will later be allowed to bring their families over, right? Do you realise the scale of this?|| Once this has been done, we can begin to think about offering these people refuge.
Do not get me wrong: I am absolutely
not against offering refuge to those who need it, but I am against letting a neverending and unlimited flow of economic migrants into Europe. You know, it's not just economic migrants. It's people from Africa and the Middle East whose beliefs, values and culture are not so compatible with our own. No, I'm not saying these people are terrorists or anything idiotic like that, but it might surprise you to learn that a large number of these people hold beliefs that most of us would see as very extreme. I take this from a source that I deem to be mostly free of bias - the Pew Forum report on Islam. Also, lest us forget the position of women in the countries that these migrants of coming from. We must be careful with this migrant crisis, as we are playing with fire.
Apparently you believe immigration is an issue. What makes certain immigrants unwanted? Who is to decide?
Should the United States have refused German and Irish immigrants?
If I get a job and come to the UK for a year or 10, am I not an immigrant? Should I be denied access?
I do believe immigration is an issue because of the way it is handled. I have no problem with someone immigrating so long as the following criteria is met :
1) They are skilled OR are coming in order to go through further education. The whole "they do the jobs we won't do!" is a load of rubbish. The number of youths needing work in the UK, for example, is huge. They will work. They must work. They cry out against the outsourcing of the jobs they need, but their voices land on deaf ears.
2) They assimilate into the culture of their new home country. Note that I do not say "integrate", as is popular. No, I do not think integration is enough. For it to work, they must assimilate. As far as I'm concerned, someone should not consider immigrating to a country unless their values and beliefs align well with the population of that country. That's the biggest step. They should relish and partake in their new country's culture, rather than stick within small communities of people from their country of birth as is so common.
Yes, if you came to the UK to work you would count as an immigrant too. Same as if I went to Germany to work! While the countries that comprise Europe are similar at their core the same rules must apply to European migrants, as we must be consistent. Being skilled and being ready to assimilate are a must. Of course, assimilating would be much easier if you are migrating between European countries, since the cultures have so much in common.