andrewjoy wrote: Regarding the text not looking good in 10.10 on none retina macs, i have just done a advanced screen calibration on the 2009 macbook i have in work and it looks way way better now i don't know whats been going on with it before i had it but it was wayyyyyy out
The issue is not that the text looks bad on any particular type of screen. The issue is the Helvetica Neue is an abysmal typeface to use for UI. Helvetica as a typeface is effective for two things: (1) corporate logos of companies that want to seem old and boring, (2) posters aiming for a particular aesthetic, [and while we’re at it, (3) keycap legends that want to look like 80s IBM]. It’s totally played out for all of these use cases, but sometimes played out is what someone is going for.
It’s a terrible typeface to use for extended text, or whenever legibility is important. As a UI font, it is a very bad choice, because to be at all legible, Helvetica must be set at a larger size, and space is at a premium for UI elements. Helvetica as a UI font makes UI text look fuzzy, sickly, cluttered.
I find it just as bad a choice on “retina” vs “non-retina” displays.